Used Ferrari 458 Italia prices
There are 26 used Ferrari 458 Italia cars for sale from UK dealers on AskCar, as of 1 November 2026. Typical asking price £196,500 (the median: half cost less, half cost more). The cheapest is £114,990. The middle half are priced between £172,500 and £203,500.
Dealers lowered the asking price on 1 of the 26 Ferrari 458 Italia cars in the 14 days to 1 November 2026.
AskCar lists 71 used Ferrari 458 across the UK, from 53 dealerships.
As of 1 November 2026, AskCar lists 578,994 cars and vans from 12,654 UK dealerships, read daily from dealer websites: over 99% of UK dealer used car adverts. No dealer pays to be listed.
Ferrari 458 Italia cars for sale now, page 1 of 2
This page picks out up to 10 cars in each of these groups: best value, cheapest, lowest mileage, recently reduced and newly advertised. A car in more than one group is listed in full once. The groups pick only from cars with photos and an AskCar estimate, priced at £500 or more and no more than 25% under that estimate. 20 of the 24 cars listed here meet these rules. Page 2 lists every other Ferrari 458 Italia car, cheapest first, including the 4 the groups do not pick from.
The AskCar estimate is our expected asking price for that one car, from its model, age, mileage and specification, using the 48 priced Ferrari 458 adverts on AskCar as of 1 November 2026. The figures on this page describe the cars advertised, not a valuation of every Ferrari 458 Italia.
Each car: year, make, model, engine and trim, power, gearbox, fuel, body, doors, colour; mileage; price and its changes; how the price compares with the AskCar estimate; emissions standard and ULEZ compliance where it holds; MOT; dealer and town; AskCar page. Each car's AskCar page has its full price history and cheaper cars like it.
This list leaves out 2 cars whose advertised mileage is lower than the mileage recorded at their last MOT test.
Best value Ferrari 458 Italia: priced furthest below the AskCar estimate
Their asking prices run from £114,990 to £214,950.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 570 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 20,000 miles. Price: £139,999, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 19 July 2026, 105 days ago. Good value: £34,623 (19%) under the AskCar estimate of £174,622. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: Digbeth Motor Sales in Birmingham. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-d17fef743780
- 2015 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, white. Mileage: 21,401 miles. Price: £199,000, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 27 October 2026, 5 days ago. Good value: £32,454 (14%) under the AskCar estimate of £231,454. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. MOT: valid until 17 June 2027. Dealer: Sytner Group in Nottingham. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2015-fa22123b4c85
- 2010 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 570 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 35,149 miles. Price: £114,990, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 28 May 2026, 157 days ago. Good value: £13,985 (10%) under the AskCar estimate of £128,975. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. MOT: the latest record we hold ran out on 2 August 2026; ask the dealer for the current MOT. Dealer: Autohaven Motors in High Wycombe. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2010-f81daba9705a
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 3,200 miles. Price: £200,000, raised by £1 from £199,999 since AskCar first saw it on 28 May 2026, 157 days ago. Good value: £19,105 (8%) under the AskCar estimate of £219,105. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: The Car Company in Leamington Spa. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-726dc65cea66
- 2010 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 570 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, black. Mileage: 25,000 miles. Price: £124,950, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 28 May 2026, 157 days ago. Good value: £11,747 (8%) under the AskCar estimate of £136,697. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. MOT: valid until 30 March 2027. Dealer: Autologix in Chesterfield. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2010-adcd9639c646
- 2015 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 570 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, black. Mileage: 39,500 miles. Price: £179,995, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 28 May 2026, 157 days ago. Good value: £16,059 (8%) under the AskCar estimate of £196,054. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: Sedgley Group in Prestwich. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2015-0ed2e34c4c11
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 36,239 miles. Price: £169,950, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 29 September 2026, 33 days ago. Fair price: £9,564 (5%) under the AskCar estimate of £179,514. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. MOT: valid until 29 April 2027. Dealer: Mayfair Prestige UK in City of Westminster. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-d7ec52c40397
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 570 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 5,400 miles. Price: £189,995, raised by £35,000 from £154,995 since AskCar first saw it on 28 May 2026, 157 days ago. Fair price: £2,485 (1%) under the AskCar estimate of £192,480. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. MOT: the latest record we hold ran out on 21 October 2026; ask the dealer for the current MOT. Dealer: Motorvana in Manchester. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-96ab61f702e7
- 2011 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, grey. Mileage: 13,750 miles. Price: £151,980, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 26 July 2026, 98 days ago. Fair price: £629 (under 1%) over the AskCar estimate of £151,351. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: Bespoke20 in Rochdale. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2011-916bcb2952a0
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, silver. Mileage: 6,974 miles. Price: £214,950, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 17 October 2026, 15 days ago. Fair price: £1,598 (under 1%) over the AskCar estimate of £213,352. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. MOT: valid until 13 May 2027. Dealer: Bell Sport & Classic in Markyate. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-e5a36f291e4a
Cheapest Ferrari 458 Italia: the lowest asking prices
These 10 are priced £114,990 to £199,000. They have covered 5,400 to 39,500 miles.
- 2010 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £114,990, 35,149 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2010 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £124,950, 25,000 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £139,999, 20,000 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2011 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £151,980, 13,750 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £169,950, 36,239 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2015 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £179,995, 39,500 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, black. Mileage: 28,500 miles. Price: £189,990, reduced by £5,000 from £194,990 since AskCar first saw it on 25 September 2026, 37 days ago. Fair price: £1,870 (under 1%) over the AskCar estimate of £188,120. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: Simon Furlonger Specialist Cars Ashford Showroom in Ashford. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-edfd60e8dc50
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £189,995, 5,400 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 570 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 19,850 miles. Price: £193,999, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 9 October 2026, 23 days ago. Above the going rate: £19,242 (11%) over the AskCar estimate of £174,757. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: Saint Motors in Bromley. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-89ce37881664
- 2015 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £199,000, 21,401 miles. Listed in full under best value.
Lowest-mileage Ferrari 458 Italia
These 10 have covered 3,200 to 20,000 miles. Their asking prices run from £139,999 to £229,990.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £200,000, 3,200 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £189,995, 5,400 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £214,950, 6,974 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2010 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats. Mileage: 7,534 miles. Price: £199,950, reduced by £15,000 from £214,950 since AskCar first saw it on 25 August 2026, 68 days ago. Above the going rate: £25,098 (14%) over the AskCar estimate of £174,852. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: Lusso Prestige in Harrow. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2010-413cfcd1ffb7
- 2011 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £151,980, 13,750 miles. Listed in full under best value.
- 2013 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 15,650 miles. Price: £229,990, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 25 September 2026, 37 days ago. Fair price: £14,453 (6%) over the AskCar estimate of £215,537. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: Simon Furlonger Specialist Cars Ashford Showroom in Ashford. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2013-89606ff6a338
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, yellow. Mileage: 17,076 miles. Price: £209,000, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 16 October 2026, 16 days ago. Fair price: £9,401 (4%) over the AskCar estimate of £199,599. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. MOT: the latest record we hold ran out on 19 October 2026; ask the dealer for the current MOT. Dealer: Sytner Group in Nottingham. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-8b98373ec27c
- 2011 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 17,150 miles. Price: £205,000, reduced by £14,000 from £219,000 since AskCar first saw it on 10 October 2026, 22 days ago. Fair price: £13,990 (7%) over the AskCar estimate of £191,010. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. MOT: valid until 16 March 2027. Dealer: Sytner Group in Nottingham. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2011-5ffb833a0f7e
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £193,999, 19,850 miles. Listed in full under cheapest.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £139,999, 20,000 miles. Listed in full under best value.
Recently reduced Ferrari 458 Italia: the biggest price reductions in the 14 days to 1 November 2026
The dealer lowered the asking price on this car in the 14 days to 1 November 2026.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £189,990, 28,500 miles. Listed in full under cheapest.
Newly advertised Ferrari 458 Italia: first seen by AskCar in the 7 days to 1 November 2026
These 3 are the most recently advertised. Cars first seen on the same day are listed cheapest first.
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 22,000 miles. Price: £204,600, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 31 October 2026, 1 day ago. Fair price: £10,032 (5%) over the AskCar estimate of £194,568. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: JCT600 Approved Leeds in Leeds. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-b1dc4fb529a2
- 2012 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia, 562 bhp, automatic, petrol, coupe, 2 doors, 2 seats, red. Mileage: 22,000 miles. Price: £209,600, unchanged since AskCar first saw it on 31 October 2026, 1 day ago. Fair price: £15,032 (7%) over the AskCar estimate of £194,568. Euro 5 emissions standard. ULEZ compliant. Dealer: JCT600 Leeds in Leeds. AskCar page: https://askcar.co.uk/car/ferrari-458-2012-9d82dd792c5a
- 2015 Ferrari 458 4.5 Italia: £199,000, 21,401 miles. Listed in full under best value.
Page 2: every other Ferrari 458 Italia car, cheapest first
Ferrari 458 by trim
More Ferrari
- All Ferrari 458 (71 cars)
- All Ferrari cars (1,102 cars)
- Ferrari Roma (84 cars)
- Ferrari 488 (83 cars)
- Ferrari Purosangue (64 cars)
- Ferrari 296 GTB (53 cars)
- Ferrari California (50 cars)
- Ferrari 296 GTS (48 cars)
- Ferrari Portofino (41 cars)
- Ferrari 360 (40 cars)
- Ferrari 12Cilindri (39 cars)
- Ferrari F355 (36 cars)
- Ferrari 812 Superfast (34 cars)
- Ferrari F430 (32 cars)
- Ferrari SF90 Spider (28 cars)
- Ferrari 488 Pista (25 cars)